bannerHON
img
HONnews
HONnews
img PATIENT / PARTICULIER img PROFESSIONNEL DE SANTE img WEBMESTRE img
img
 
img
HONcode sites
Khresmoi - new !
HONselect
News
Conferences
Images

Themes:
A B C D E F G H I
J K L M N O P Q
R S T U V W X Y Z
Browse archive:
2014: D N O S A J J M A M F J
2013: D

 
  Other news for:
Brain
Physicians
Headache
Health Care Costs
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Migraine
 Resources from HONselect
Too Many Unneeded Brain Scans for Headaches, Study Suggests
Routine use of imaging tests not recommended, but more docs ordering them anyway, researcher says

By Steven Reinberg
HealthDay Reporter

MONDAY, March 17, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- Too many patients are getting unnecessary brain scans for headaches, and that use is growing, according to a new study.

Since most headaches are benign, guidelines have recommended against routine MRIs or CT scans. Yet doctors frequently order these expensive scans anyway, the researchers say.

"During headache visits, brain scans are ordered an incredible amount of the time," said lead researcher Dr. Brian Callaghan, an assistant professor of neurology at the University of Michigan Health System, in Ann Arbor.

"There are a lot of MRIs and a lot of CTs and that adds up to a lot of money," he pointed out. "It's about $1 billion a year."

Brain scans for headaches jumped from about 5 percent of patient visits in 1995 to nearly 15 percent in 2010, the researchers found.

While brain scans are good for some patients, they are unnecessary for most, Callaghan noted. "Most people with headaches don't need any testing," he said.

Among the reasons these tests are not recommended is that they can often find some abnormality, which although benign, could lead to further unnecessary tests and treatment, he explained.

"In 1 to 3 percent of people you will find something on the MRI, whether it be a tumor or blood vessel malformation. You don't want to find something you weren't looking for. It can be anxiety provoking," Callaghan said.

Brain scans can cost as much as $4,000. Insurance, including Medicare, only pays from $500 to $2,000, Callaghan said.

For the study, Callaghan's team used data from a national survey on outpatient medical care to look at all adult patients seen for headache from 2007 through 2010. Most patients were younger than 65 and about three-quarters were women.

The study found there were a total of roughly 51 million patient visits for headache, including about 25 million for migraines. MRIs or CTs were performed in more than 12 percent of all visits for headache and in nearly 10 percent of visits for migraine.

The researchers estimated the cost of all these scans in the four-year period at $3.9 billion.

"The number-one reason physicians give is patient reassurance. It's harder to talk a patient out of it than to just get the scan," Callaghan said. "But I would argue that patient reassurance isn't worth $1 billion a year."

In addition, doctors order scans out of fear they might miss a serious condition and be sued for misdiagnosis, he noted.

The profit motive also comes into play, Callaghan added. "Facilities make a lot of money off of these tests," he said.

Patients also have a role, Callaghan said. "Imaging for headaches is on the list of tests patients should question," he said.

The report was published online March 17 as a research letter in JAMA Internal Medicine.

Guidelines from the American Academy of Family Physicians, American Academy of Neurology and the American College of Emergency Physicians recommend against routine brain scans for headache (in the absence of other indications).

The study could not verify whether scans were ordered according to guidelines or not, but showed that they occurred in the context of a headache-related visit to a doctor.

"Though this study shows levels of imaging that are undoubtedly excessive and costs that almost certainly exceed the benefits, it does not measure or discuss the benefits of brain imaging in patients with headache," said Dr. Richard Lipton, vice chairman of neurology and director of the Montefiore Headache Center at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, in New York City.

These benefits include finding a brain tumor, stroke, brain abscess and bleeding into the brain, according to Lipton, who was not involved with the new study. Reassuring worried patients that they do not have a serious or life-threatening condition is important, he said.

In addition, scans reduce the doctor's concern that they might have missed a serious condition, as well as concerns about the liability that may arise from a failure to diagnose.

"The reality is that most headaches are benign, but distinguishing high-risk and low-risk presentations is not that easy," Lipton said. "I agree that optimizing headache brain imaging practices should be a priority."

More information

For more about headache, visit the U.S. National Library of Medicine.

SOURCES: Brian Callaghan, M.D., assistant professor of neurology, University of Michigan Health System, Ann Arbor; Richard Lipton, M.D., vice chairman, neurology, and director, Montefiore Headache Center, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New York City; March 17, 2014, JAMA Internal Medicine, online

Copyright © 2014 HealthDay. All rights reserved. URL:http://consumer.healthday.com/Article.asp?AID=685878

Resources from HONselect: HONselect is the HON's medical search engine. It retrieves scientific articles, images, conferences and web sites on the selected subject.
Headache
Brain
Research Personnel
Physicians
Neoplasms
Lead
The list of medical terms above are retrieved automatically from the article.

Disclaimer: The text presented on this page is not a substitute for professional medical advice. It is for your information only and may not represent your true individual medical situation. Do not hesitate to consult your healthcare provider if you have any questions or concerns. Do not use this information to diagnose or treat a health problem or disease without consulting a qualified healthcare professional.
Be advised that HealthDay articles are derived from various sources and may not reflect your own country regulations. The Health On the Net Foundation does not endorse opinions, products, or services that may appear in HealthDay articles.


Home img About us img MediaCorner img HON newsletter img Site map img Ethical policies img Contact